Skip to content
FreedomClock

Answers: Should I save in a Roth or a traditional account?

Roth vs. Traditional Calculator

Compare what Roth and traditional contributions leave you after tax, and find your break-even tax rate.

  • Instant results
  • Private — runs in your browser
  • Free, no sign-up

Your numbers

$
22%
15%
years
%

Traditional comes out ahead by

$35,473

Paying 22% tax today versus 15% in retirement, the traditional account leaves you $35,473 more to spend after 30 years, after every tax is paid.

Break-even retirement rate: 19.7%Traditional saves $1,650/yr in tax now

Roth, after tax

$758,048

Withdrawals are tax-free

Traditional, after tax

$793,521

Includes $149K of invested tax savings

Break-even rate

19.7%

Retire below this rate → traditional wins

You contribute

$225,000

$7,500 a year for 30 years

Where Roth and traditional cross

Traditional wins if your retirement tax rate ends up below 19.7%; Roth wins above it. Your estimate is 15%.

Roth (same at any rate)TraditionalYour expected rate

After-tax money at retirement

What you could actually spend from each choice, after all taxes.

Why equal tax rates tie

Taxing money before it grows or after it grows gives the same answer, because multiplication works in any order: $10,000 × 0.78 × 5 = $10,000 × 5 × 0.78 = $39,000. So the real question is whether your tax rate will be higher or lower when you withdraw. Here the break-even sits a bit below today’s rate because the invested tax savings pay capital-gains tax (15% assumed) on their growth.

How this Roth vs. traditional calculator works

You choose how much to contribute each year, your tax rate today, the tax rate you expect in retirement, how long the money grows and your expected return. The calculator puts the same contribution into each account type and compares what you could actually spend at retirement after every tax is paid.

The math

Roth after tax = C × F

Traditional after tax = C × F × (1 − retirement rate) + invested tax savings

C is your yearly contribution and F is how much each yearly dollar grows to by retirement (a standard annuity factor at your expected return). Roth withdrawals are tax-free, so the full balance is yours. Traditional withdrawals are taxed as income, but you also saved C × today’s rate in taxes every year you contributed. With the fair-comparison setting on, those savings are invested in a taxable account, and their growth pays capital-gains tax (15% assumed) when you cash out.

Reading the break-even chart

The flat teal line is the Roth: its after-tax value doesn’t depend on your future tax rate. The navy line is traditional: the higher your retirement tax rate, the less you keep. Where they cross is your break-even rate. If you expect to retire at a rate below it, traditional wins; above it, Roth wins. The dashed line marks your own estimate, so you can see how much room for error you have.

The break-even usually lands a little below your current rate, because the invested tax savings sit in a taxable account while every Roth dollar grows tax-free. If you’re contributing the maximum, a Roth effectively shelters more money.

When each one tends to win

  • Roth: early in your career, in a low bracket, expecting higher income later, or wanting tax-free money that won’t raise your taxable income in retirement.
  • Traditional: in your peak earning years, in a high bracket, or planning to retire somewhere with lower taxes.
  • Both: unsure where tax rates are headed. Holding both lets you choose which account to draw from each year.

What this leaves out

The calculator assumes a single flat tax rate on withdrawals. In reality, withdrawals fill brackets gradually, Social Security may become taxable, and Medicare premiums rise at higher incomes. Roth accounts also have no required minimum distributions for the original owner, which helps estate and tax planning.

Frequently asked questions

Is Roth or traditional better?+

It mostly comes down to your tax rate today versus your tax rate when you withdraw. If you expect a lower rate in retirement, traditional tends to win; if you expect a higher rate, Roth tends to win. When the two rates are equal, the outcomes are nearly identical.

Why do equal tax rates give the same result?+

Because multiplication works in any order. Taxing $10,000 at 22% and then letting it grow five-fold gives $10,000 × 0.78 × 5 = $39,000. Letting it grow first and taxing it at 22% gives $10,000 × 5 × 0.78, the same $39,000. Roth taxes the seed and traditional taxes the harvest, so the rate is what matters.

Why does the calculator invest the traditional tax savings?+

A traditional contribution lowers your tax bill today, so it costs less take-home pay than the same Roth contribution. To compare choices that cost the same, the calculator assumes you invest that difference in a regular brokerage account. If you’d spend it instead, Roth wins at any retirement tax rate above 0%. Turn the setting off to see that.

What tax rate should I expect in retirement?+

Start with the income you expect: Social Security, pensions, and the withdrawals you’ll need. Many retirees drop a bracket because they no longer earn a salary. But large traditional balances, required minimum distributions and future tax-law changes can push rates up. If you’re unsure, splitting contributions between Roth and traditional is a reasonable hedge.

Are there income limits for Roth contributions?+

For a Roth IRA, yes: the amount you can contribute phases out at higher incomes (for 2026 the phase-out starts at $153,000 of modified AGI for single filers). Roth 401(k) contributions have no income limit, and you can split your 401(k) contributions between Roth and traditional under the same annual limit.

How do state taxes affect the choice?+

Add your state rate to both your current and retirement rates in More options. If you plan to retire in a state with no income tax, such as Florida, Texas or Nevada, traditional contributions made in a high-tax state can be especially valuable, because you deduct at today’s state rate and pay nothing to the state later.

Keep going

Freedom Clock for iPhone

Carry your freedom date in your pocket.

  • Save a base plan + unlimited what-ifs
  • Stress-test crashes and life events
  • Log money wins — see days gained
  • Quarterly check-ins keep you on track

Roth vs. Traditional results are estimates for educational purposes only and are not financial, tax, legal or investment advice. Verify important decisions with a qualified professional..