How this Roth vs. traditional calculator works
You choose how much to contribute each year, your tax rate today, the tax rate you expect in retirement, how long the money grows and your expected return. The calculator puts the same contribution into each account type and compares what you could actually spend at retirement after every tax is paid.
The math
Roth after tax = C × F
Traditional after tax = C × F × (1 − retirement rate) + invested tax savings
C is your yearly contribution and F is how much each yearly dollar grows to by retirement (a standard annuity factor at your expected return). Roth withdrawals are tax-free, so the full balance is yours. Traditional withdrawals are taxed as income, but you also saved C × today’s rate in taxes every year you contributed. With the fair-comparison setting on, those savings are invested in a taxable account, and their growth pays capital-gains tax (15% assumed) when you cash out.
Reading the break-even chart
The flat teal line is the Roth: its after-tax value doesn’t depend on your future tax rate. The navy line is traditional: the higher your retirement tax rate, the less you keep. Where they cross is your break-even rate. If you expect to retire at a rate below it, traditional wins; above it, Roth wins. The dashed line marks your own estimate, so you can see how much room for error you have.
The break-even usually lands a little below your current rate, because the invested tax savings sit in a taxable account while every Roth dollar grows tax-free. If you’re contributing the maximum, a Roth effectively shelters more money.
When each one tends to win
- Roth: early in your career, in a low bracket, expecting higher income later, or wanting tax-free money that won’t raise your taxable income in retirement.
- Traditional: in your peak earning years, in a high bracket, or planning to retire somewhere with lower taxes.
- Both: unsure where tax rates are headed. Holding both lets you choose which account to draw from each year.
What this leaves out
The calculator assumes a single flat tax rate on withdrawals. In reality, withdrawals fill brackets gradually, Social Security may become taxable, and Medicare premiums rise at higher incomes. Roth accounts also have no required minimum distributions for the original owner, which helps estate and tax planning.