Skip to content
FreedomClock

Answers: Will I be wealthier renting or buying a home?

Rent vs. Buy Calculator

Net worth from buying versus renting and investing the difference, and how long you’d need to stay for buying to win.

  • Instant results
  • Private — runs in your browser
  • Free, no sign-up

Your numbers

$
$/mo
20% · $80K
%
10 years

Buying wins after

7 yrs 1 mo

Stay 10 years and buying leaves you about $23,437 richer than renting and investing the difference.

Cash to buy

$92,000

Down payment + closing costs

Owning per month

$2,806

Year 1, vs. $2,200 rent

If you buy

$259,102

Net worth after 10 years

If you rent

$235,665

Net worth after 10 years

Your net worth: buying vs. renting

Buyer = home equity after selling costs (plus any savings invested). Renter = down payment, closing costs and monthly savings, invested. The shading shows who’s ahead.

If you buyIf you rent

What each path really costs over 10 years

Money that’s gone for good. Mortgage principal isn’t a cost — you get it back as equity when you sell.

Buying$279,210
  • Mortgage interest$193,998
  • Property tax$42,233
  • Maintenance$46,926
  • Insurance & HOA$20,635
  • Closing costs$12,000
  • Selling costs$33,854
  • Investment growth given upWhat the renter’s invested cash earned beyond yours$93,804
  • Home price gain−$164,240
Renting$302,646
  • Rent paid$302,646

Buying costs $23,437 less, the same as the gap between the two net-worth lines when you move.

How this rent vs. buy calculator works

The calculator follows two versions of you, month by month, for as long as you plan to stay. Both spend exactly the same amount on housing plus investing, so the only difference is where that money goes.

  • The buyer pays the down payment and closing costs, then each month’s mortgage payment, property tax, insurance, maintenance, HOA dues and any PMI. Their net worth is what they would walk away with if they sold: the home’s value, minus selling costs, minus the remaining loan.
  • The renter pays rent and invests the down payment and closing costs on day one. In any month when owning would have cost more than rent, the renter invests the difference. If renting ever costs more (rent keeps rising while a fixed mortgage payment doesn’t), the owner invests that difference instead.

Buyer net worth = home value × (1 − selling costs) − loan balance + owner’s invested savings

Renter net worth = (down payment + closing costs + monthly savings) grown at your investment return

Reading the chart

The two lines are each path’s net worth over time. The shaded area between them takes the color of whoever is ahead. The buyer usually starts behind, because closing and selling costs are lost the moment you buy. The point where the lines cross is the break-even: stay longer than that and buying comes out ahead.

What each path really costs

The cost panel adds up money that’s gone for good on each side. For buying, that means interest, taxes, insurance, upkeep and transaction costs, minus any rise in the home’s value and any tax savings. Mortgage principal isn’t counted, because you get it back as equity. Each side also “pays” the investment growth it gives up. The difference between the two totals is exactly the gap between the net-worth lines when you move.

Assumptions and limits

  • Property tax and maintenance are a percentage of the home’s current value. Insurance and HOA dues rise with rent.
  • PMI is charged below 20% down until the loan reaches 78% of the original price.
  • Returns are before tax. Profit on a primary home is often tax-free up to $250,000 ($500,000 for married couples), while a taxable investment account may owe some capital-gains tax, so the renter’s side is slightly flattered.
  • The mortgage-interest deduction is optional and covers interest on the first $750,000 of debt. When it’s on, the calculator assumes you’d itemize anyway, so all of that interest lowers your tax at your marginal rate. The property-tax deduction isn’t counted.

Owning also has benefits a calculator can’t price, like stability and the freedom to renovate. Renting has its own, like flexibility and no surprise repair bills. Treat the numbers as one input to the decision.

Frequently asked questions

Is it better to rent or buy a home?+

It depends mostly on how long you’ll stay, how home prices and rents in your area are likely to grow, and what you could earn by investing instead. Buying carries large one-time costs (closing costs when you buy, commissions when you sell), so it usually takes several years to pay off. The longer you stay, the more likely buying wins.

What is the break-even point in rent vs. buy?+

It’s the month your net worth as an owner (home equity after selling costs) pulls ahead of what you’d have if you had rented and invested the difference, and stays ahead. Sell before then and you end up behind the renter.

Isn’t renting just throwing money away?+

Not exactly. Owners also have money that’s gone for good: mortgage interest, property taxes, insurance, maintenance and the costs of buying and selling. Rent is the renter’s version of those costs. The fair comparison is total unrecoverable cost on each side, which is what the “What each path really costs” panel shows.

Why does the renter’s side assume investing?+

Buying ties up a down payment and closing costs, and often costs more per month than renting at first. If you rent instead, that money is still yours. Assuming it’s invested keeps the comparison honest. If you’d spend it instead, renting will look better here than it would be in real life.

Should I count the mortgage interest deduction?+

Only if you itemize. For 2026 the standard deduction is $16,100 for single filers and $32,200 for married couples filing jointly, so many homeowners never itemize and get no extra benefit from mortgage interest. If you do itemize, interest on up to $750,000 of mortgage debt is deductible. Turn the option on only if your other deductions already beat the standard deduction; the calculator then counts every dollar of that interest at your marginal rate. It doesn’t count the property-tax deduction.

What assumptions matter most?+

Years you’ll stay, home price growth versus investment return, and the rent-to-price ratio. Move home price growth or the investment return by one percentage point and you’ll see how sensitive the answer is. Nobody can predict either one.

Keep going

Freedom Clock for iPhone

Carry your freedom date in your pocket.

  • Save a base plan + unlimited what-ifs
  • Stress-test crashes and life events
  • Log money wins — see days gained
  • Quarterly check-ins keep you on track

Rent vs. Buy results are estimates for educational purposes only and are not financial, tax, legal or investment advice. Verify important decisions with a qualified professional..