How this rent vs. buy calculator works
The calculator follows two versions of you, month by month, for as long as you plan to stay. Both spend exactly the same amount on housing plus investing, so the only difference is where that money goes.
- The buyer pays the down payment and closing costs, then each month’s mortgage payment, property tax, insurance, maintenance, HOA dues and any PMI. Their net worth is what they would walk away with if they sold: the home’s value, minus selling costs, minus the remaining loan.
- The renter pays rent and invests the down payment and closing costs on day one. In any month when owning would have cost more than rent, the renter invests the difference. If renting ever costs more (rent keeps rising while a fixed mortgage payment doesn’t), the owner invests that difference instead.
Buyer net worth = home value × (1 − selling costs) − loan balance + owner’s invested savings
Renter net worth = (down payment + closing costs + monthly savings) grown at your investment return
Reading the chart
The two lines are each path’s net worth over time. The shaded area between them takes the color of whoever is ahead. The buyer usually starts behind, because closing and selling costs are lost the moment you buy. The point where the lines cross is the break-even: stay longer than that and buying comes out ahead.
What each path really costs
The cost panel adds up money that’s gone for good on each side. For buying, that means interest, taxes, insurance, upkeep and transaction costs, minus any rise in the home’s value and any tax savings. Mortgage principal isn’t counted, because you get it back as equity. Each side also “pays” the investment growth it gives up. The difference between the two totals is exactly the gap between the net-worth lines when you move.
Assumptions and limits
- Property tax and maintenance are a percentage of the home’s current value. Insurance and HOA dues rise with rent.
- PMI is charged below 20% down until the loan reaches 78% of the original price.
- Returns are before tax. Profit on a primary home is often tax-free up to $250,000 ($500,000 for married couples), while a taxable investment account may owe some capital-gains tax, so the renter’s side is slightly flattered.
- The mortgage-interest deduction is optional and covers interest on the first $750,000 of debt. When it’s on, the calculator assumes you’d itemize anyway, so all of that interest lowers your tax at your marginal rate. The property-tax deduction isn’t counted.
Owning also has benefits a calculator can’t price, like stability and the freedom to renovate. Renting has its own, like flexibility and no surprise repair bills. Treat the numbers as one input to the decision.