Skip to content
FreedomClock

Answers: Is this rental property (or home) a better investment than the stock market?

Rental Property & Real Estate Return Calculator

Cash flow, cap rate and IRR for a rental, compared with investing the same cash in stocks.

  • Instant results
  • Private — runs in your browser
  • Free, no sign-up

Your numbers

$
25% · $87.5K
$/mo
%
years
8% / yr

Your annual return (IRR)

8.8%

Over 10 years this rental returns 8.8% a year on your cash — 0.8% a year more than stocks at 8%.

This property8.8%
Bought with all cash7.8%
Stock market8%

Cash flow, month 1

−$237/mo

You add this each month

Cash needed up front

$98,000

25% down + buying costs

Cap rate

5.2%

Cash-on-cash return: -2.9% in year 1

Wealth after 10 years

$245K

vs. $228K in stocks

Rent doesn’t cover the mortgage and costs in year 1

You’d add about $237 a month at first (debt coverage ratio 0.86). Many investment-property lenders look for a ratio of about 1.2 or higher.

Your wealth: this property vs. the stock market

Both sides put in the same cash each month. Property = equity if you sold (after selling costs and the loan) + surplus rent invested in stocks.

This propertyStocks

Where your profit comes from

Total profit over 10 years: $137,474 on $98,000 up front (2.28× your money back).

Leverage adds 1% a year to your return

Borrowing at 7% to buy an asset that earns more raises your return on cash: 8.8% with a mortgage vs. 7.8% paying cash. Leverage magnifies losses the same way if prices fall.

Returns are before income taxes for both property and stocks (no depreciation, mortgage-interest deduction or capital-gains tax), and assume steady growth — real markets move in cycles.

How this real estate calculator works

Pick whether you’ll rent the property out or live in it, enter the price, down payment, rent and mortgage rate, and the calculator projects every month you own it. Rent (or the rent you avoid by owning) rises each year, costs rise with home values and inflation, and your mortgage balance falls with each payment. When you sell, it subtracts selling costs and the remaining loan to find the cash you walk away with.

The numbers that matter

  • Cash flow: rent − vacancy − management − property tax − insurance − maintenance − HOA − mortgage payment.
  • Cap rate: year-one net operating income ÷ purchase price, the property’s yield before financing.
  • Cash-on-cash: year-one cash flow ÷ the cash you put in.
  • IRR: the annual return that accounts for every dollar in and out, including the sale.

0 = −Cash in + Σ Cash flowₜ ÷ (1 + r)ᵗ + Sale equity ÷ (1 + r)ᴺ → solve for r

Where profit comes from

Profit comes from cash flow, loan paydown (the rent you collect or avoid pays down the mortgage) and appreciation. Leverage magnifies all three relative to the cash you put in. Transaction costs work against you: buying and selling a home commonly costs 8–10% of its value in total, which is why short holding periods rarely pay off.

Rental property or stocks?

A rental can beat stocks when it’s bought at a solid cap rate, financed sensibly and held long enough for appreciation and paydown to compound. Stocks win on simplicity, liquidity and diversification — no tenants, repairs or vacancies. Use the stock-return slider to test both conservative and optimistic assumptions, and remember that both returns here are before taxes.

Frequently asked questions

What is IRR, and why use it for real estate?+

IRR (internal rate of return) is the annual discount rate at which the present value of all an investment’s cash flows (the money you put in, the monthly cash flow, and what you get back when you sell) adds up to zero. It captures everything real estate returns depend on: cash flow, loan paydown, appreciation and timing. Because a stock index fund’s return is also an annual rate, IRR lets you compare the two directly.

What’s a good cap rate or cash-on-cash return?+

Cap rate is year-one net operating income (rent minus operating costs, before the mortgage) divided by the price. Many U.S. markets trade at roughly 4–8%. Cash-on-cash is year-one cash flow after the mortgage divided by the cash you put in. Neither includes appreciation or loan paydown, which is why IRR is the better all-in measure.

How does leverage change my return?+

Borrowing lets you control a bigger asset with less cash. When the property’s all-in return beats your mortgage rate, leverage raises your return on cash. When it doesn’t, leverage lowers it, and it magnifies losses if prices fall. The calculator shows your return with the mortgage and with an all-cash purchase so you can see the effect.

How is the comparison with stocks made fair?+

Both paths start with the same cash (down payment plus buying costs) and put in the same money every month. When the property needs cash to cover a shortfall, the stock investor invests that same amount; when the property throws off extra cash, the owner invests it in stocks. The property comes out ahead exactly when its IRR beats the stock return you choose.

How does the “Live in it” mode work?+

It treats owning your home as an investment whose “income” is the rent you no longer pay. Each month, the rent you’d otherwise pay for a similar home is compared with the full cost of owning: mortgage, property tax, insurance, maintenance and HOA. The renter invests the down payment, buying costs and any monthly difference in stocks instead.

Does this include taxes?+

No. Results are before income taxes for both the property and the stock alternative. Real-estate investors may benefit from depreciation and deductions but owe depreciation recapture and capital-gains tax on sale; homeowners may exclude up to $250,000 ($500,000 married) of gain on a primary home. A tax professional can help with your situation.

Keep going

Freedom Clock for iPhone

Carry your freedom date in your pocket.

  • Save a base plan + unlimited what-ifs
  • Stress-test crashes and life events
  • Log money wins — see days gained
  • Quarterly check-ins keep you on track

Rental Property / IRR results are estimates for educational purposes only and are not financial, tax, legal or investment advice. Verify important decisions with a qualified professional..